
Educational Boundaries, Rewards, and Punishments
Introduction
Raising children and adolescents is a complex journey that requires a deep understanding of their psychological and brain development. Setting consistent boundaries and using rewards and punishments appropriately are fundamental strategies to promote healthy growth, yet the approach may vary depending on the chosen parenting style. In this article, we will explore the role of boundaries, managing power struggles, and the importance of rewards and punishments during different stages of development, from early childhood to adolescence. We will also examine how these tools influence the behaviour of children and teenagers.
Educational Boundaries and Their Consistency
Boundaries provide children and adolescents with a sense of security and structure. When boundaries are consistent and well-defined, they encourage the development of self-regulation and emotional management. Various studies, including one conducted by Gilliom et al. (2002), show that children who grow up with clear boundaries are better able to regulate themselves and handle stressful situations more effectively.
However, the need for and method of setting boundaries evolve over time, adapting to the different stages of brain and psychological development.
Ages 0-2: Developing a Sense of Security
During the first year of life, children are in a phase of sensory and physical exploration of the world around them. Their brains are developing rapidly, particularly in areas responsible for emotions and attachment. According to Shonkoff and Phillips (2000), this is when children lay the foundation for secure attachment, which profoundly influences their ability to trust others and regulate their emotions in the future.
Boundaries at this age: At this stage, especially during the first year of life, children do not understand verbal boundaries but respond to non-verbal cues (such as tone of voice, smiles, and proximity) and interactions with their parents. Children are extremely sensitive to changes in tone; they may become frightened and confused by yelling but can be soothed by a parent's closeness.
As they grow, children begin to understand verbal instructions, though they lack the ability to grasp concepts like the passage of time.
Ages 2-5: Understanding Rules
From the age of 2, children start developing the ability to understand simple rules and the consequences of their actions. Their brain development, particularly in the prefrontal areas, makes them more aware of social dynamics and emotions, both their own and others’. During this phase, they can comprehend basic verbal rules and respond to symbolic rewards, such as praise or small privileges, for positive behaviours.
It is crucial that boundaries are clear and age-appropriate. For example, children at this age struggle to understand abstract concepts of time; instead of vague phrases like "later" or "tomorrow afternoon," it is better to use precise instructions like "when we eat" or "tomorrow after school."
Children in this phase often test their boundaries, including relational ones. What might appear as defiance or a power struggle is often driven by their natural need for exploration and learning. Since they lack fully developed cognitive abilities to understand the consequences of their actions, maintaining consistent and clear boundaries is essential. Frequent changes in rules, especially in response to tantrums, may teach children that persistence can alter boundaries, creating a cycle of increasingly insistent behaviour.
Ages 6-12: Developing Morality and Social Competition
From ages 6 to preadolescence, children develop a more complex understanding of the world and social relationships. This is the stage where they begin recognising broader social rules and comparing themselves to others. Brain development continues, particularly in areas related to logic and critical thinking (Brown, 2000).
Boundaries in school-age children: Children at this age respond well to logical explanations of why boundaries are important. They may also start negotiating boundaries and testing authority. It is vital for parents to maintain consistency, explaining the consequences of breaking rules while encouraging autonomy, which is essential for personal growth and self-esteem development.
Adolescence: Challenges, Autonomy, and Power
Adolescence represents one of the most critical phases of development. This stage is characterised by a strong drive for autonomy and often by rebellion against boundaries. Adolescents, who are in the process of forming their identities, may perceive parental boundaries as obstacles to their freedom.
At this stage, boundaries should be less rigid than those set for younger children and more oriented towards discussion and negotiation. Adolescents need to feel involved in the decision-making process while understanding the consequences of their actions. Striking a balance between autonomy and supervision is crucial for fostering healthy and responsible behaviour.
Rewards and Punishments: Effective Strategies Across Ages
Positive reinforcement (rewards) and negative reinforcement (punishments) are powerful tools in raising children and adolescents but must be used carefully. According to B.F. Skinner (1953), positive reinforcement is more effective in promoting desirable behaviours than punishment, which can lead to resentment or oppositional behaviour, especially in adolescents.
Rewards: Rewards should be tied to desired behaviours and age-appropriate. For younger children, simple praise or small material rewards can be effective. For adolescents, rewards such as increased autonomy or social recognition can motivate positive behaviours.
Punishments: Punishments should be used sparingly. Studies show that overly harsh punishments can have long-term negative effects, such as increased aggression and behavioural problems. This is especially true for physical punishments.
The fear of consequences often leads to avoiding those consequences rather than avoiding the undesirable behaviour itself. Clear and consistent boundaries, and when necessary, the temporary removal of privileges, are more effective and less harmful.
A piece of advice: it is always better to avoid linking rewards or punishments to food (except for special occasions). Eating disorders often stem from educational boundaries related to food and the associated need for control.
Conclusions
Setting consistent boundaries, using rewards and punishments judiciously, and understanding power dynamics are essential for fostering healthy development in children and adolescents. Each developmental stage requires a different approach, but consistency, understanding, and open communication remain the keys to success.Â
Â
Written by
Dr Elizabeth Moore, Psychologist
(consultation only in Italian)
For clarifications regarding the article or to book an appointment in person or online, please visit the Contacts section or call
Consultations are available in Italian only
Bibliography
Martha Stout, Il male che ci ha fatti (2007), Giunti Editore
Patrick Carnes, Donne che amano troppo (2007), Edizioni Corbaccio
Cristina Gatti, Il narcisismo nelle relazioni affettive (2016), Franco Angeli
Heinz-Peter Röhr, Il narcisista: come riconoscerlo e difendersi (2018), Edizioni Il Punto d'Incontro
Francesca Gino, Narcisismo: come riconoscere il disturbo e affrontarlo (2019), Franco Angeli
External resources
"If you wish to explore the topic of psychological manipulation further and find relevant articles and studies, consider these important academic and institutional resources."
American Academy of Pediatrics (AAP)Un'importante risorsa per articoli e linee guida sui comportamenti infantili e sull'educazione positiva. Puoi visitare il loro sito per cercare informazioni pertinenti.Link: American Academy of Pediatrics
Child Development JournalQuesta rivista pubblica ricerche su vari aspetti dello sviluppo infantile, inclusi studi sull'importanza dei limiti educativi e delle dinamiche familiari. Puoi cercare articoli specifici sul loro sito.Link: Child Development
National Institute of Child Health and Human Development (NICHD)Fornisce ricerche e risorse sull'infanzia e lo sviluppo, coprendo temi come il comportamento infantile e le tecniche educative efficaci.Link: NICHD
Sito del Ministero dell'IstruzioneFornisce informazioni e risorse riguardanti l'educazione e lo sviluppo dei bambini, con focus su pratiche educative efficaci in contesti nazionali.Link: Ministero dell'Istruzione
Rivista Italiana di Educazione FamiliareUna risorsa nazionale per articoli di ricerca sull'educazione, con un focus su studi e approcci specifici al contesto italiano.Link: Rivista Italiana di Educazione Familiare